NEEDS FIX
24 descriptive-legal claim(s) flagged for optional human review (advisory): ['c-001', 'c-002', 'c-003', 'c-011', 'c-012', 'c-110', 'c-111', 'c-013', 'c-014', 'c-016', 'c-017', 'c-018', 'c-019', 'c-112', 'c-113', 'c-121', 'c-122', 'c-116', 'c-117', 'c-118', 'c-020', 'c-021', 'c-022', 'c-023']; citation gate(s) flagged: ['C-2 placements 18-34', 'C-6 tier mix (>=3 in T1-3, >=2 T4)']; 5 of 42 claim(s) carry no verdict: the deterministic checker settles legal claims only and the semantic verifiers were not run. Each is bound byte-exact to a frozen source at S4, which is why the article renders, but byte-exactness is not a semantic verdict
source: showcase-run-receipt.json · legal check: PASS · 2780 rendered words (draft body 2520w)
1. The published article
This is the exact article.html the pipeline produced — the 29-element page that would go live on the blog (brand styling, table of contents, Key Takeaways, the compliance notice before the body, FAQ, numbered Sources, and the machine-readable Article + FAQ data). Publishing is paused; nothing was sent anywhere.
embedded file: article.html · open full page
2. The journey
Every article moves through the same numbered stages. Each move is recorded in the article's manifest.yaml with who did it and when — the article cannot skip a gate.
| Move | By | When (UTC) | What happened |
|---|
| (created) → 01-queued | orchestrator | 2026-08-13T13:01:11 | |
| 01-queued → 02-briefing | brief-agent | 2026-08-14T11:10:14 | 3.1-3.11 outline built and frozen |
| 02-briefing → 03-drafting | writer-agent | 2026-08-14T11:11:28 | stage S4 |
source: manifest.yaml
3. QA Gate 1 — the outline, before a word was written
Before drafting, five independent checks run on the outline. This is where the system refuses to build on an unsupported claim. Each check reports how many items it looked at, how many failed, and out of how many (checked / failed / denominator).
Attempt 1 PASS · 2026-08-14T11:10:14| Check | Result | checked/failed/denom | Detail |
|---|
| product-accuracy | PASS | 21/0/21 | tier T1b: 0 product-class claim(s) among 21 declared; 0 SSOT records frozen and available as the enum |
| legal-frame-and-position | PASS | 26/0/26 | 21 claim frames + 5 triggered elements; ordering sub-check not applicable: outline plans 0 legal and 0 commercial section(s); an ordering constraint n |
| citation-entails-claim | PASS | 21/0/21 | 21 of 21 planned claims carry an assigned frozen source; 0 declared without one; 0 P3 claim(s) resolved INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE and are REMOVED from the |
| competitor | PASS | 21/0/21 | 21 source/link origins resolved against 10 blocked competitor domains and 4 recognised market-context domains |
| structure-and-link-liveness | PASS | 13/0/13 | 8 sections + 5 required elements; link-liveness sub-check not applicable: the outline plans zero outbound links (predicate `planned_links is non-empty |
Attempt 1 PASS · 2026-08-14T11:23:21| Check | Result | checked/failed/denom | Detail |
|---|
| product-accuracy | PASS | 23/0/23 | tier T1b: 0 product-class claim(s) among 23 declared; 0 SSOT records frozen and available as the enum |
| legal-frame-and-position | PASS | 28/0/28 | 23 claim frames + 5 triggered elements; ordering sub-check not applicable: outline plans 0 legal and 0 commercial section(s); an ordering constraint n |
| citation-entails-claim | PASS | 23/0/23 | 23 of 23 planned claims carry an assigned frozen source; 0 declared without one; 0 P3 claim(s) resolved INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE and are REMOVED from the |
| competitor | PASS | 23/0/23 | 23 source/link origins resolved against 10 blocked competitor domains and 4 recognised market-context domains |
| structure-and-link-liveness | PASS | 13/0/13 | 8 sections + 5 required elements; link-liveness sub-check not applicable: the outline plans zero outbound links (predicate `planned_links is non-empty |
Attempt 1 PASS · 2026-08-14T11:32:06| Check | Result | checked/failed/denom | Detail |
|---|
| product-accuracy | PASS | 22/0/22 | tier T1b: 0 product-class claim(s) among 22 declared; 0 SSOT records frozen and available as the enum |
| legal-frame-and-position | PASS | 27/0/27 | 22 claim frames + 5 triggered elements; ordering sub-check not applicable: outline plans 0 legal and 0 commercial section(s); an ordering constraint n |
| citation-entails-claim | PASS | 22/0/22 | 22 of 22 planned claims carry an assigned frozen source; 0 declared without one; 0 P3 claim(s) resolved INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE and are REMOVED from the |
| competitor | PASS | 22/0/22 | 22 source/link origins resolved against 10 blocked competitor domains and 4 recognised market-context domains |
| structure-and-link-liveness | PASS | 13/0/13 | 8 sections + 5 required elements; link-liveness sub-check not applicable: the outline plans zero outbound links (predicate `planned_links is non-empty |
source: outline-qa-log.json
4. QA Gate 2 — the finished draft
After the full article is written, five verifiers re-check the finished draft — product accuracy, legal accuracy, citations, competitor safety, and structure — and an adjudicator decides the outcome. In this zero-cost run the legal and citation checks are deterministic (exact-match against the sources), which is stronger than an AI opinion and needs no paid API.
| Verifier | Result | checked/failed/denom | Detail | From |
|---|
| product | PASS | 42/0/42 | tier T1a: 0 product-class claim(s) of 42 declared; product claims resolve to catalog/ssot/ssot.json | claims.json |
| legal | PASS | 6/0/25 | deterministic pool match: 1 SUPPORTED, 0 CONTRADICTED, 5 INSUFFICIENT, 19 HUMAN_REVIEW | legal-verify-receipt.json |
| citation | FAIL | 11/2/11 | 9/11 citation gates PASS; 12 sources / 42 placements / reuse 3.5 | render-receipt.json |
| competitor | PASS | 13/0/13 | 12 cited source host(s) + body scanned against 10 blocked competitor domain(s); hits=none | draft.md + competitor-allowlist.json |
| structure | PASS | 25/18/25 | 7/25 structural elements present; 2780 rendered words vs 2500 floor (delivery-gate measure; draft body 2520w) | render-receipt.json + article.html (delivery-gate word count) |
Adjudicator: NEEDS-FIX — 24 descriptive-legal claim(s) flagged for optional human review (advisory): ['c-001', 'c-002', 'c-003', 'c-011', 'c-012', 'c-110', 'c-111', 'c-013', 'c-014', 'c-016', 'c-017', 'c-018', 'c-019', 'c-112', 'c-113', 'c-121', 'c-122', 'c-116', 'c-117', 'c-118', 'c-020', 'c-021', 'c-022', 'c-023']; citation gate(s) flagged: ['C-2 placements 18-34', 'C-6 tier mix (>=3 in T1-3, >=2 T4)']; 5 of 42 claim(s) carry no verdict: the deterministic checker settles legal claims only and the semantic verifiers were not run. Each is bound byte-exact to a frozen source at S4, which is why the article renders, but byte-exactness is not a semantic verdict
word floor: 2780 rendered words (delivery-gate measure; draft body 2520w) vs 2500 · source: stage-report-S5-S7.json + editorial-review.json
5. Claim-accuracy table — every claim, traced
This is the heart of the proof. Every checkable claim in the article is listed with: the single-source-of-truth it draws on (LEGAL-SSOT = the legal folder, PRODUCT-SSOT = the product catalogue, OEM-TECHNICAL = manufacturer spec sheets), the source's own words (“before”), the verdict, and how it was checked. “After” — our paraphrase — is the claim text itself in column 2.
| Claim / verdict | Our text (after) | Value | Single source of truth | Source's own words (before) | Method |
|---|
c-001 INSUFFICIENT | The Environmental Protection Agency names the prohibitions on tampering as Clean Air Act section 203(a)(3) and 40 C.F.R. §§ 1068.101(b). | 203 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-19 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-002 INSUFFICIENT | The Clean Air Act prohibits anyone from tampering with an emission control device on a motor vehicle by removing it or making it inoperable, whether before or after the sale to the | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-23 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-003 HUMAN REVIEW | The prohibitions apply for the entire life of the vehicle, and they apply regardless of whether the regulatory useful life or the warranty period has ended. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-18 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-004 — | Cummins describes the 2021 engine as bringing more horsepower and torque than its predecessor. | 2021 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-07 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-101 — | Cummins publishes the 2021 power rating as a range of 370 - 420 hp. | 2021 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-07 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-102 — | It publishes the torque rating for the same model year as a range of 850 - 1075 lb-ft. | 850 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-07 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-024 — | For the Ram 2500 and 3500 fitted with the 68RFE automatic, Cummins records that horsepower and torque increased to 370 hp and 850 lb-ft. | 2500 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-07 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-103 — | Cummins records the high-output engine at 420 hp and 1,075 lb-ft of torque. | 420 hp | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-07 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-104 — | That high-output rating is offered exclusively in the Ram 3500 equipped with the Aisin transmission option. | 3500 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-07 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-026 — | The 2019 model year introduced HD pickup buyers to 1000 lb-ft of torque for the first time ever. | 2019 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-12 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-105 — | Cummins engines have been an option in Ram pickups since 1989. | 1989. | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-06 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-106 — | The first Cummins-powered Ram arrived with 400 pounds-feet of torque, which Cummins describes as having roared past the competition of the day. | 400 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-06 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-107 — | Cummins reports that nearly 70% of Ram 2500 and 3500 Heavy Duty pickup owners choose the Cummins Turbo Diesel as their powertrain. | 70% | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-12 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-010 — | Ram's press material for the model year publishes a towing capacity of 35,100 pounds and a payload capacity of 7,680 pounds for the 2021 Ram Heavy Duty. | 35,100 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-28 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-108 — | In a common rail fuel system, diesel is stored in a high-pressure rail that supplies each injector independently. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-09 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-109 — | That arrangement holds a constant and consistent high pressure, which allows precise control over injection timing and quantity. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-09 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-011 HUMAN REVIEW | When EPA decides whether service on an emissions element was tampering, it compares the element after the service against its fully functioning certified configuration. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-17 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-012 HUMAN REVIEW | A part that alters how the computer controls fuel is a defeat device. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-17 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-110 HUMAN REVIEW | EPA records that required emission controls often include filters and catalysts in the exhaust system as well as calibrations that manage fueling strategy and other operations in t | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-111 INSUFFICIENT | The Clean Air Act prohibits tampering with emissions controls, as well as manufacturing, selling, and installing aftermarket devices intended to defeat those controls. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-013 HUMAN REVIEW | An off-road or competition-only label on a part does not create a legal exemption, because there is no Clean Air Act exemption for a vehicle used only off-road or only for racing. | — | LEGAL-SSOT (folder) s-authorities | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-014 HUMAN REVIEW | EPA has found that competition-only claims are unsupported by any showing of competition-only use. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-19 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-015 SUPPORTED | Tampering, including installing a defeat device, can void manufacturer warranties. | — | LEGAL-SSOT lg-src-178 | “42 U.S.C. § 7541 (Clean Air Act §207), 'Compliance by vehicles and engines in actual use', establishes the federal emission warranty: the manufacturer” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-016 HUMAN REVIEW | Federal warranty law puts the burden on the warrantor to show that the aftermarket part caused the failure. | — | LEGAL-SSOT (folder) s-authorities | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-017 HUMAN REVIEW | For any person other than a manufacturer or dealer, the maximum is $5,911 per motor vehicle or engine. | $5,911 | LEGAL-SSOT (folder) s-authorities | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-018 HUMAN REVIEW | For a manufacturer or dealer, the maximum is $59,114 per motor vehicle or engine. | $59,114 | LEGAL-SSOT (folder) s-authorities | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-019 HUMAN REVIEW | Those amounts are maxima rather than fixed amounts. | — | LEGAL-SSOT (folder) s-authorities | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-112 HUMAN REVIEW | EPA finalized 172 civil enforcement cases from FY 2020 through FY 2023, and those cases produced civil penalties totalling $55.5 million. | 172 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-113 HUMAN REVIEW | EPA also supported states performing inspections and taking enforcement actions for violations of state laws concerning tampering. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-114 — | Known sales of defeat devices for certain diesel trucks after 2009 and before 2020 resulted in more than 570,000 tons of excess nitrogen oxides over the lifetime of the trucks. | 2009 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-121 HUMAN REVIEW | By making aftermarket defeat devices a National Enforcement and Compliance Initiative, EPA addressed what it called a significant contributor to air pollution. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-122 HUMAN REVIEW | From FY 2020 through FY 2023 that initiative focused on stopping the manufacture, sale and installation of defeat devices on vehicles and engines used on public roads as well as on | 2020 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-115 — | During FY 2023, EPA resolved 38 civil enforcement cases. | 2023, | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-116 HUMAN REVIEW | EPA has found numerous companies and individuals that manufactured and sold both hardware and software specifically designed to defeat required emissions controls. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-117 HUMAN REVIEW | States' efforts to curtail demand for aftermarket defeat devices complement the agency's own, which are generally focused on the manufacturing and supply of those devices | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-118 HUMAN REVIEW | From FY 2020 through FY 2023 the agency provided tampering and aftermarket defeat device inspector trainings attended by 26 states and the District of Columbia. | 2020 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-119 — | The same sales produced 5,000 tons of excess particulate matter over the lifetime of those trucks. | 5,000 | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-120 — | Illegally modified vehicles and engines contribute substantial excess pollution that harms public health and impedes efforts by the EPA, tribes, states and local agencies to plan f | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-16 | “” | Frozen source span (byte-exact) |
c-020 HUMAN REVIEW | EPA generally takes no enforcement action where a person restores the element to its certified configuration. | — | OEM-TECHNICAL oem-17 | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-021 INSUFFICIENT | CARB must deny an Executive Order exemption request if the device will reduce the effectiveness of the emissions control system. | — | LEGAL-SSOT (folder) s-authorities | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-022 INSUFFICIENT | A part whose function is to reduce emissions-control effectiveness can never receive an Executive Order. | — | LEGAL-SSOT (folder) s-authorities | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
c-023 HUMAN REVIEW | In California, Vehicle Code section 27156 separately prohibits installing, selling, offering for sale or advertising such a device. | 27156 | LEGAL-SSOT (folder) s-authorities | “” | Deterministic exact-match vs legal pool |
source: claims.json (+ legal-verify-receipt.json for legal verdicts)
6. Citation provenance — the paper trail
Each numbered reference in the article traces back to a single source of truth and, from there, to the underlying .gov statute or manufacturer page. A source is linked once and reused by number thereafter (the hyperlink-once rule).
25
Legal claims → legal SSOT
0
Product claims → product SSOT
17
Technical claims → OEM specs
12
Distinct sources (2 legal / 10 OEM/KB / 0 product)
source: render-receipt.json + claims.json by_type
7. Waivers — what the engine refused to invent
When a required part of an article has no source behind it, the engine does not write it anyway. It records a waiver: the element, the reason, and exactly which sources were checked and found empty. This is the rule that would have prevented the August 2026 incident — an element with nothing behind it is declared missing, never filled in with something plausible. Below is every waiver on this article, so the gap is a decision you can see and overrule rather than a silence you would have to notice.
Element 3 — Key Takeawaysno key_takeaways in metadata (author in 2b)
Sources checked and found empty:
metadata.json:key_takeawaysmetadata.json:keyTakeaways
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 4 — Introductionno intro in metadata (author in 2b)
Sources checked and found empty:
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 20 — Vehicle compatibility tableno product on this article carries a fitment record in the catalogue
Sources checked and found empty:
catalogue:products[].fitment
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 22 — Technical specs tableno product on this article carries variant records in the catalogue
Sources checked and found empty:
catalogue:products[].variants
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 8 — Expert quoteno claim on this article is declared as a quote, and the profile's technical-sources pool is a domain allowlist that carries no quotations, so no sourceable attributed quote exists
Sources checked and found empty:
<article>/claims.json:type=quote<article>/claims.json:evidence.kind=quoteprofiles/<client>/technical-sources.json
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 9 — FAQno faq in metadata (author in 2b)
Sources checked and found empty:
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 16 — The Bottom Lineno bottom_line in metadata (author in 2b)
Sources checked and found empty:
metadata.json:bottom_line
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 24 — Internal link blockno internal_links in metadata (author in 2b)
Sources checked and found empty:
metadata.json:internal_links
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 27 — Named author biono author_bio/credentials in metadata (author in 2b)
Sources checked and found empty:
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 25 — Entity optimization blockno product entities on this article and no publisher entity to state
Sources checked and found empty:
profile.yaml:display_name<article>/callouts.json
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 26 — Owned data / customer review blockno product referenced by this article carries a review aggregate in the catalogue, and there is no review text anywhere in it to quote
Sources checked and found empty:
catalogue:products[].reviews.ratingcatalogue:products[].reviews.count
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 11 — AI block (GEO)the block reuses the Key Takeaways bullets and none exist (element 3 is itself waived)
Sources checked and found empty:
metadata.json:key_takeawaysmetadata.json:keyTakeaways
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
Element 23 — Visible update datemetadata carries no date_modified, and the render clock is not a substitute for a recorded edit date
Sources checked and found empty:
metadata.json:date_modified
Decided 2026-08-14 17:01:06 UTC
source: waivers.json · cross-checked against the 13 waiver notice(s) rendered in article.html
8. Copied word-for-word? — overlap with the sources
A paraphrase is supposed to differ from its source — that is what makes it a paraphrase. This measures the opposite: how many of the article's words sit inside a run of 8 or more consecutive words that also appears, exactly, in one of the frozen sources the writer worked from. This is shown, never enforced. It cannot block or delay anything, because some overlap is correct — legal wording has to track the statute closely, and a model name or a torque figure has one right spelling. Read a high number as "go and look", not as "this is wrong".
20.9%
Words inside a copied run
32
Longest copied run (words)
Low — consistent with paraphrasing, not copying · flag threshold 30%, a review trigger rather than a limit — nothing is blocked at any value
The longest copied runs, and where each came from:
| Length | Source | The copied words |
|---|
| 32w | oem-16 | “Illegally
modified vehicles and engines contribute substantial excess pollution that harms public
health and impedes efforts by the EPA, tribes, states and local agencies to plan for and
att” |
| 27w | oem-16 | “focused on stopping the
manufacture, sale and installation of defeat devices on vehicles and engines used on public
roads as well as on nonroad vehicles and engines.” |
| 24w | oem-16 | “Known sales of defeat
devices for certain diesel trucks after 2009 and before 2020 resulted in more than 570,000
tons of excess nitrogen oxides” |
| 21w | oem-16 | “EPA also
supported states performing inspections and taking enforcement actions for violations of
state laws concerning tampering. States' efforts to curtail” |
| 20w | oem-23 | “prohibits anyone from
tampering with an emission control device on a motor vehicle by removing it or making it
inoperable,” |
| 19w | oem-16 | “prohibits
tampering with emissions controls, as well as manufacturing, selling, and installing
aftermarket devices intended to defeat those controls.” |
| 18w | oem-12 | “The 2019 model
year introduced HD pickup buyers to 1000 lb-ft of torque for the first time ever.” |
| 18w | oem-16 | “exhaust system as well as calibrations that manage fueling strategy and other operations in
the engine itself.
The” |
| 17w | oem-16 | “provided tampering and aftermarket defeat
device inspector trainings attended by 26 states and the District of Columbia.” |
| 16w | oem-12 | “Ram 2500 and 3500 Heavy Duty pickup owners choose the
Cummins Turbo Diesel as their powertrain.” |
| 14w | oem-07 | “rating is offered exclusively in the Ram 3500 equipped with the Aisin transmission option.” |
| 14w | oem-16 | “manufactured and sold both hardware and
software specifically designed to defeat required emissions controls.” |
Words copied, by source:
| Source | Words |
|---|
oem-16 | 230 words |
s-authorities | 125 words |
s-legal-gate | 57 words |
oem-12 | 34 words |
oem-23 | 20 words |
oem-18 | 18 words |
s-usa-regs | 18 words |
oem-07 | 14 words |
oem-27 | 13 words |
oem-28 | 13 words |
oem-30 | 13 words |
oem-31 | 13 words |
Read the draft with the copied runs highlighted — every highlight names the source it matches
# 2021 Cummins Delete: Which Truck You Have, and What Federal Law Says
Before the legal question there is a factual one, and a surprising number of owners get it
wrong about this particular model year. A 2021 Ram Heavy Duty did not come one way. Two
different factory calibrations were published for the same engine, they went into different
trucks, and which one is under your hood changes what a modification could actually gain
you. This article covers that first, then the law. What follows is a technical and legal
reference rather than advice on your own circumstances.
## The short answer
The Environmental Protection Agency names the prohibitions on tampering as Clean Air Act
section 203(a)(3) and 40 C.F.R. §§ 1068.101(b). The Clean Air Act prohibits anyone from
tampering with an emission control device on a motor vehicle by removing it or making it
inoperable,oem-23 whether before or after the sale to the buyer.
Neither of the two things owners expect to change that does. The prohibitions apply for the
entire life of the vehicle, and they apply regardless of whether the regulatory useful life
oroem-18 the warranty period has ended.
## Which 2021 truck do you have
Cummins describes the 2021 engine as bringing more horsepower and torque than its
predecessor. What is easy to miss is that the increase was not applied uniformly across the
range.
Cummins publishes the 2021 power rating as a range of 370 - 420 hp. It publishes the torque
rating for the same model year as a range of 850 - 1075 lb-ft.
A range is not a spec. It is two ratings printed in one place, and the gap between the ends
of it is wider than most aftermarket claims. Every engine output figure below is from that
same Cummins engine page; the towing and payload figures further down are from Ram's press
material for the model year.
**Standard output, in the 2500 and the 3500.**
For the Ram 2500 and 3500 fitted with the 68RFE automatic, Cummins records that horsepower
and torque increased to 370 hp and 850 lb-ft.
**High output, in the 3500 only.**
Cummins records the high-output engine at 420 hp and 1,075 lb-ft of torque. That high-output
rating is offered exclusively in the Ram 3500 equipped with the Aisin transmission option.oem-07
That restriction is the part worth checking before anything else, and it gives you a test
you can run in your own driveway. The high-output calibration was tied to a particular
automatic transmission, and the standard-output calibration to a different one. If your
truck is a 2500 it has the standard-output calibration whatever a general summary of the
engine says. If it is a 3500, the transmission it was built with is what separates the two.
The reason that test works is that these are not trim levels. They are two published ratings
on one engine, certified as they left the factory, and the difference between them is not a
part you can see by opening the hood.
The torque history is worth knowing too, because it is frequently misdated. The 2019 model
year introduced HD pickup buyers to 1000 lb-ft of torque for the first time ever.oem-12 The
partnership behind it runs a long way further back than that. Cummins engines have been an
option in Ram pickups since 1989.oem-06 The first Cummins-powered Ram arrived with 400 pounds-feet
of torque, which Cummins describes as having roared past the competition of the day.
Cummins reports that nearly 70% of Ram 2500 and 3500 Heavy Duty pickup owners choose the
Cummins Turbo Diesel as their powertrain.oem-12 That is context for how ordinary this engine is in
the segment rather than an argument about any particular truck.
## What that means for the power argument
Most delete conversations are really power conversations, so it is worth putting the factory
capability figures where they can be seen. These come from Ram's own press material for the
model year rather than from the engine page, because towing and payload are properties of
the truck rather than of the engine.
Ram's press material for the model year publishes a towing capacity of 35,100 pounds and a
payload capacity of 7,680 poundsoem-27, oem-28, oem-30 for the 2021 Ram Heavy Duty.
The practical consequence is that the headroom people imagine is being measured against a
factory calibration that was already near the top of what the segment offered. Where a truck
is already on the high-output rating, the gap between what it makes now and what any
modification could deliver is narrower than the reputation suggests. Where it is on the
standard-output rating, the more useful question is what the factory's own high-output
calibration involved, because that is a difference the manufacturer engineered and certified
rather than one somebody added afterwards.
It also helps to know where the difference between two ratings on one engine actually lives.
In a common rail fuel system, diesel is stored in a high-pressure rail that suppliesoem-09 each
injector independently. That arrangement holds a constant and consistent high pressure,
which allows precise control over injection timing and quantity.
So the distance between the two published ratings on this engine is mostly a matter of what
the controller commands and when, not of different metal. That is why a power conversation
about this truck is a software conversation almost immediately — and it is exactly why the
legal boundary below is drawn around software as well as hardware.
## What federal law prohibits
The prohibition reaches further than lifting a part off the truck, and the test the agency
applies is a comparison rather than a judgement about why the work was done. When EPA
decides whether service on an emissions element was tampering, it compares the element after
the service against its fully functioning certified configuration.
Software sits inside that same boundary, which is the part most often assumed otherwise. A
part that alters how the computer controls fuel is a defeat device. A calibration written to
suit absent aftertreatment is describing itself in those terms.
The agency is explicit that the controls it means are not only the parts you can point at.
EPA records that required emission controls often include filters and catalystsoem-16 in the
exhaust system as well as calibrations that manage fueling strategy and other operations in
the engine itself.
Theoem-16 prohibition also runs in both directions of a transaction. The Clean Air Act prohibits
tampering with emissions controls, as well as manufacturing, selling, and installing
aftermarket devices intended to defeat those controls.oem-16 An owner and a seller are therefore
looking at the same statute from two different positions.
## Off-road and competition labels
An off-road or competition-only label on a part does not create a legal exemption, because
there is no Clean Air Act exemption for a vehicle used only off-road or only for racing.
What the label records is a seller's description of intended use.
The agency has also tested that claim against what sellers can actually show. EPA has found
that competition-only claims are unsupported by any showing of competition-only use.
## Warranty
Tampering, including installing a defeat device, can void manufacturer warranties. On a
truck of this age the powertrain coverage may well have run out already, but the emissions
consequences are separate from the warranty question and outlast it.
The qualifier is worth knowing too. Federal warranty law puts the burden on the warrantor to
show that the aftermarket part caused the failure. So a denial still has to connect the
modification to the specific failure being claimed.
## What the exposure is
The governing statute is 42 U.S.C. § 7524, and the figures actually in force are the
inflation-adjusted ones published at 40 C.F.R. § 19.4 today. Two amounts apply to two
different classes of party, and they are frequently reported the wrong way round.
For any person other than a manufacturer or dealer, the maximum is $5,911s-authorities, s-legal-gate per motor vehicle
or engine. For a manufacturer or dealer,s-authorities, s-legal-gate the maximum is $59,114 per motor vehicle or engine.
Those amounts are maxima rather than fixed amounts. The statute makes the assessor weigh
gravity, economic benefit, business size and compliance historys-authorities before landing on a number.
It is fair to ask whether any of this is enforced in practice, and the agency publishes its
own answer. By making aftermarket defeat devices a National Enforcement and Compliance
Initiative,oem-16 EPA addressed what it called a significant contributor to air pollution. EPA
finalized 172 civil enforcement cases from FY 2020 through FY 2023,oem-16, s-authorities and those cases produced
civil penalties totalling $55.5 million. During FY 2023, EPA resolved 38 civil enforcement
cases.oem-16
The listed targets of that initiative are worth reading closely if you are having work done
rather than doing it. From FY 2020 through FY 2023 that initiative focused on stopping the
manufacture, sale and installation of defeat devices on vehicles and engines used on public
roads as well as on nonroad vehicles and engines.oem-16 Installation is named alongside
manufacture and sale, so the shop doing the work is inside the same sentence as the company
that made the part.
Where those cases landed is worth noting, because it is not where owners assume. EPA has
found numerous companies and individuals thatoem-16 manufactured and sold both hardware and
software specifically designed to defeat required emissions controls.oem-16 The two halves of that
sentence are the point: the software was treated the same way as the hardware, and the
sellers were the ones in front of the agency.
The division of labour between federal and state enforcement follows from that. EPA also
supported states performing inspections and taking enforcement actions for violations of
state laws concerning tampering. States' efforts to curtailoem-16 demand for aftermarket defeat
devices complement the agency's own, which are generally focused on the manufacturing and
supply ofoem-16 those devices. So the seller-side focus does not mean an owner sits outside the
system; it means the two levels of government are working different ends of the same market.
Between them, the agency also invested in the inspection capability that finds modified
trucks. From FY 2020 through FY 2023 the agency provided tampering and aftermarket defeat
device inspector trainings attended by 26 states and the District of Columbia.oem-16
The scale of what that enforcement was aimed at is published as well. Known sales of defeat
devices for certain diesel trucks after 2009 and before 2020 resulted in more than 570,000
tons of excess nitrogen oxidesoem-16 over the lifetime of the trucks. The same sales produced
5,000 tons of excess particulate matter over the lifetime of those trucks. Illegally
modified vehicles and engines contribute substantial excess pollution that harms public
health and impedes efforts by the EPA, tribes, states and local agencies to plan for and
attain air quality standards.oem-16 Those figures are the reason the agency treats this as an air
quality problem rather than a paperwork one.
## The compliant path
Where a truck has already been modified, there is a defined route back. EPA generally takes
no enforcement action where a person restores the element to its certified configuration.oem-17, oem-18
For a road-registered truck the compliant categories are parts holding a California Air
Resources Board Executive Order, emissions-intact tuning that does not alter an emissions
control element, and restoration to factory configuration. Nothing sold as a delete belongs
in that first category. CARB must deny an Executive Order exemption request if the device
will reduce the effectiveness of the emissions control system.s-authorities
A part whose function is to reduce emissions-control effectiveness can never receive ans-authorities
Executive Order. So the category is closed by design rather than by a queue. In California,
Vehicle Code section 27156 separately prohibits installing, selling, offering for sale or
advertising such a device.
---
## Legal notice
This article is educational and describes federal requirements as published by the EPA, the
Code of Federal Regulations and the engine and vehicle manufacturers. It is not legal
advice.
Removing, disabling, bypassing or defeating an emissions control device on a vehicle
certified for highway use is prohibited under the Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. § 7522(a)(3), and
40 C.F.R. § 1068.101(b). Civil penalties under 42 U.S.C. § 7524, as adjusted by 40 C.F.R. §
19.4 for violations assessed on or after 8 January 2025,s-legal-gate reach a **maximum of $5,911** per
motor vehicle or engine for any person other than a manufacturer or dealer,s-authorities, s-legal-gate and a **maximum
of $59,114** per motor vehicle or engine for a manufacturer or dealer.s-authorities, s-legal-gate These are maxima
rather than fixed amounts: 42 U.S.C. § 7524(b)–(c)(2) requires the assessor to weigh
gravity, economic benefit, business size and compliance history.s-authorities These prohibitions apply
for the entire life of the vehicle and apply regardless of whether the warranty or
regulatory useful-life period has ended. Tampering may void the vehicle warranty. A part
labelled for off-road, competition or closed-course use does not create an exemption for a
vehicle that is registered or operated on public roads.
## Sources
1. Cummins, 6.7L Turbo Diesel (2021) — https://www.cummins.com/engines/products/cummins-67l-turbo-diesel-2021
2. Cummins, Cummins-Ram history — https://www.cummins.com/engines/pickup-truck/cummins-ram-history
3. Cummins, Pickup Truck — https://www.cummins.com/engines/pickup-truck
4. Cummins, Fuel System Technologies — https://www.cummins.com/components/engine-components/fuel-systems
5. Stellantis media, Ram Heavy Duty press kit — https://media.stellantisnorthamerica.com/newsrelease.do?id=21972
6. EPA, National Enforcement and Compliance Initiative: Stopping Aftermarket Defeat Devicess-authorities, s-usa-regs — https://www.epa.gov/enforcement/national-enforcement-and-compliance-initiative-stopping-aftermarket-defeat-devices
7. EPA, Tampering and Defeat Devices enforcement alert — https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2020-12/documents/tamperinganddefeatdevices-enfalert.pdf
8. EPA, Enforcement Policy on Vehicle and Engine Tamperingoem-19, s-usa-regs — https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2020-12/documents/epatamperingpolicy-enforcementpolicyonvehicleandenginetampering.pdf
9. EPA, Tampering and Aftermarket Defeat Devices (2019 MCDI presentation) — https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2019-05/documents/tampering-aftermarket-defeat-devices-2019-mcdi-mtg-33pp.pdf
10. EPA, Air Enforcement — https://www.epa.gov/enforcement/air-enforcement
11. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, 40 C.F.R. § 19.4 — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-40/chapter-I/subchapter-A/part-19/section-19.4
12. 42 U.S.C. § 7522, United States Code via GovInfo — https://www.govinfo.gov/link/uscode/42/7522?link-type=html
13. 42 U.S.C. § 7524, United States Code via GovInfo — https://www.govinfo.gov/link/uscode/42/7524?link-type=html
14. 16 C.F.R. § 700.10, Code of Federal Regulations via GovInfo — https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2022-title16-vol1/pdf/CFR-2022-title16-vol1-sec700-10.pdf
15. California Air Resources Board, Procedures for Exemption of Add-On and Modified Partss-authorities — https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/barcu/board/15day/ampts/proceduresfinal.pdf
source: lib/overlap over draft.md vs frozen/sources/*.txt · measured on the authored draft, not the rendered page, so the legal notices and catalogue product text — which are verbatim by design — cannot inflate it
9. Verdict
NEEDS FIX
24 descriptive-legal claim(s) flagged for optional human review (advisory): ['c-001', 'c-002', 'c-003', 'c-011', 'c-012', 'c-110', 'c-111', 'c-013', 'c-014', 'c-016', 'c-017', 'c-018', 'c-019', 'c-112', 'c-113', 'c-121', 'c-122', 'c-116', 'c-117', 'c-118', 'c-020', 'c-021', 'c-022', 'c-023']; citation gate(s) flagged: ['C-2 placements 18-34', 'C-6 tier mix (>=3 in T1-3, >=2 T4)']; 5 of 42 claim(s) carry no verdict: the deterministic checker settles legal claims only and the semantic verifiers were not run. Each is bound byte-exact to a frozen source at S4, which is why the article renders, but byte-exactness is not a semantic verdict
source: showcase-run-receipt.json · legal check: PASS · 2780 rendered words (draft body 2520w)